American Chemicals & Equipment Inc. 401(K) Retirement Plan v. Principal Management Corp.

ACE filed suit against LifeTime Funds' investment adviser, PMC, for breach of its section 36(b) fiduciary duty to the LifeTime Funds under the Investment Company Act (ICA) of 1940, 15 U.S.C. 80a-35(b). ACE based its excessiveness-of-adviser-fees challenge on all or part of the adviser fees paid to PMC by the funds in which the LifeTime Funds invest, fees which indirectly reduced the net asset values of the LifeTime Funds. The Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court's entry of judgment for PMC based on lack of statutory standing, holding that ACE cannot sue on behalf of a fund in which it lacks an interest. In this case, each mutual fund was a separate unregistered investment company and ACE had no security interest in the underlying funds. Therefore, the cross appeal and the motion to dismiss the cross appeal were moot or denied as moot. View "American Chemicals & Equipment Inc. 401(K) Retirement Plan v. Principal Management Corp." on Justia Law